BDA response to the RCN’s change of position on NHS pay

8 March 2022

The BDA and our partner NHS unions have issued a joint statement in response to a change of position on NHS pay by the Royal College of Nursing (RCN).

Annette Mansell-Green, Director of Trade Union and Public Affairs says:

“The BDA signed up to a collective position on pay for all NHS staff to form part of an urgent NHS retention package with an inflation busting pay rise as a priority.

“All 14 NHS unions engaged in extensive discussion on how this would be best achieved and following a vote, came to the unanimous decision that we could only do this by standing together in unity as a collective group, working together to fight for the best possible outcome for our members and the patients they serve.

“We are therefore deeply disappointed to find that the Royal College of Nursing has breached that agreement by publishing an alternative stance which undermines the position of the 13 remaining signatories. The statement below contains the response of the other 13 unions, including the BDA and explains that we are resolute in campaigning together to achieve our joint aims.”

“It is only through working together in unity that we will achieve the best for our members and all those that rely on the NHS.”


Joint statement in full

The NHS unions are deeply disappointed that the RCN has taken the decision to back out of the collective position on NHS pay agreed by everyone in January and confirmed in a formal vote of the Staff Council staff side. 

All 14 unions signed up to the collective call for an urgent NHS retention package, with an inflation-busting pay rise at its heart. This package, which aims to help the NHS hold on to increasingly disillusioned staff, formed the basis of the joint union evidence submitted to the NHS pay review body last month.

The submission set the key conditions by which unions would judge any pay outcome. Crucially, the retention package was designed to generate a ‘unity position’ after the multi-claim approach taken in the previous pay round.

All the unions had concluded that a shared position was an essential element of the campaigning power necessary to achieve a decent outcome on pay this year. The RCN had been strong advocates for a collective position and voted in support when the staff
council decision was originally taken.  

Sadly, the RCN has now breached this agreement by announcing a separate position for 2022-23, preventing Agenda for Change staff from speaking with one voice on pay this year.  

It was a conscious decision of the joint unions not to put a number against an expected pay rise. Many unions had set figures last year when a negotiated approach was a real prospect and after months of government silence in response to calls to negotiate an ‘early and significant’ pay rise for health workers.

Even in that relatively stable economic situation, inflation jumped four percentage points between submitting evidence and receiving the eventual outcome. Given the current economic and political volatility, unions considered it risky to set a rate when forecasts differ wildly about how high living costs will rise throughout the whole pay year.  

The retention package set out by the joint unions is an ambitious and credible proposal to halt the exodus of staff from the health service. In addition to calling for an inflation-busting pay rise, we want to see action to ensure staff are banded properly for the jobs they do and get fair reward for the additional hours they regularly work. 

The unions also want to see staff protected from burnout and for recruitment and retention premia to be applied to the roles suffering the most shortages. The joint staff side is calling for this package of measures to be placed alongside a wage rise that absorbs costs and starts a programme of pay restoration. 

The pandemic has amplified the value and mutual respect health workers have for their colleagues and led to recognition that our members are all part of the same team. So, in approaching the 2022-23 pay round, unions were keen to have a joint position to enable the strong campaigning necessary to achieve a decent outcome.  

Inevitably, the decision of the RCN to pull away from the collective position will prevent it from being part of  joint campaign activity on pay this year.  

The 13 other NHS unions remain resolute behind the joint position and have vowed to work together for the benefit of all NHS staff. This includes providing a strong voice for health workers in the TUC‘s cost of living crisis campaign. They all deeply regret that the RCN won’t be able to make the anticipated contribution to the campaign in support of the retention package, but will look to work collegiately with that union wherever possible. 

It is only through working together in unity that we will achieve the best for our members and all those that rely on the NHS. 

The NHS Agenda for Change unions signing this statement are:

  1. The British Association of Occupational Therapists
  2. The British Dietetic Association
  3. The British Orthoptists Society
  4. The Chartered Society of Physiotherapy
  5. The Federation of Clinical Scientists
  6. GMB
  7. Managers in Partnership
  8. The Prison Officers Association
  9. The Royal College of Midwives
  10. The Royal College of Podiatry
  11. The Society of Radiographers
  12. UNISON
  13. Unite the union

Together they represent hundreds of thousands of health staff in all non-medical
roles across the NHS.